Luke 24
33-107    108-199    200-300    301-400    401-500    501+    all heritics

——————————————————————————
Luke 24
Original Sources:
First Users and
First Functions


Theodotus (Eclogue 42) in ~200: “Thus also it is said, The lord lives, and the lord has risen.” Function: like Clement Alx this writer seems to have been in the school of Pantenus, and was both a Gnostic and an OT lover.

Paul in ~58, at 1 Cor 15:5, is first to tell us: “and was seen by Cephas.”

Anonymous in ~255 at Rebaptism 9: “and some of themselves, even when they had seen him, did not believe, but doubted.” Function: again, to show that error was rife even among the chosen, so Cyprian should not want to rebaptise restored heretics.

Tertullian in 207 at Adv. Marc. 4,43 reports the doubts of many caused by Marcion’s claim that Christ was not a real physical human, but perhaps only a literary construct, a spiritual entity: He says to them, Why are you troubled, and why do doubts arise in your hearts?

Look, my hands and my feet, that it is I myself; for a spirit has not bones, as you see me have.” Function: physical detail like hands and feet are very important against Marcion.
Justin Martyr in ~160 (Resurr 9): “When his disciples (people like Marcion and the Jews) did not know whether to believe he had truly risen in the body and were looking upon him and doubting, he said to them: You don’t yet have trust, see that I am myself. And he let them handle him, and showed them the prints of the nails in his hands. And when they were by every kind of proof persuaded that it was himself, and in the body, they asked him to eat with them, that they might thus still more accurately ascertain that he had in verity risen bodily; and he ate honey-comb and fish.” Function: a description of the now alarming problem in the church in Justin’s later years: the Gnostic denial of the physical reality of Christ, among other orthodox doctrines, especially “that we possess eternal duration from the excelling power of this Being” (5,2,3).

Ignatius of Antioch ~107 (Sm 3): Feel me and see, because I am not a demon, incorporeal.” Function: vs. the docetists (Grk “seeming”) with their idea of a “seemingly real,” but only a virtual or phantom Christ.

Marcion, (as reported by Tertullian, Flesh of Christ 5 in ~207) is the one to touch off the debate with his opposition to Ignatius in ~160: “A spirit such as you see me to be does not have bones.” Irenaeus in ~185 tries to reverse Marcion: “we are members of his body, of his flesh, and of his bones. He does not speak these words of some spiritual and invisible man, for a spirit has not bones nor flesh.” This is a saying of Christ for Marcion, but Irenaeus is still troubled about it, and does not present even his attempt at a correction as a saying.

Gospel text as found since ~350 in X and B, unless otherwise indicated.




34 The lord has risen indeed,




     and was seen by Simon.


37 And they became shaken and scared
     thinking to be watching a spirit.





38 And he said to them, Why are you
     disturbed and why do doubts rise
     in your hearts?






39 See my hands and my feet
     that I am myself.






















     Feel me and see, because





     a spirit has not flesh and bones as
     you observe me
having.


Home | © Copyright 1997-2002 Aretee Publications. All rights reserved.

922